Pinchit
Type to search topics, or add a question about your city

Best burger in New York?

60 pinches
  1. 1
    9 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    Shake Shack 366 Columbus Ave.
  2. 2
    4 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    Bare Burger 514 3rd Avenue
  3. 3
    3 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    Burger Joint 190 Bleecker St
  4. 4
    2 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    BLT Corporate Office 6th Ave & W 21st St
  5. 5
    2 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    DuMont Burger 314 Bedford Ave.
  6. 6
    2 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    Pop Burger 14 E. 58th St
  7. 7
    2 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    Mel's Burger Bar 2850 Broadway
  8. 8
    2 pinches
    Edit Pinch ×
    Go Burger 310 W 38th St
  9. 9
    5 Napkin Burger 630 9th Ave.
  10. 10
    Bobby's Burger Palace 610 Bergen Town Center
  11. 11
    Whitmans 406 E 9th St.
  12. 12
    Black Iron Burger 540 E 5th St
  13. 13
    Corner Bistro 331 W 4th St.
  14. 14
    Brooklyn Label 180 Franklin St.
  15. 15
    Skinflints Restaurant 7902 5th Ave
  16. 16
    Mehtaphor 130 Duane St
  17. 17
    Lucky's Famous Burgers 264 W 23rd St.
  18. 18
    Grand Canyon Restaurant 141 Montague St
  19. 19
    5 Napkin Burger 630 9th Ave.
  20. 21
    Frites 'n' Meats Greenwich St & Chambers St
  21. 22
    Piper's Kilt Of Inwood 207 Broadway
  22. 23
    goodburger 870 Broadway
  23. 24
    Bareburger 535 Laguardia Pl
  24. 25
    Zaitzeff 18 Avenue B
  25. 26
    Mercer Kitchen 99 Prince St
  26. 28
    The Spotted Pig 314 W 11th St.
  27. 30
    Ruby's Cafe 219 Mulberry St
  28. 31
    Kool Bloo Soho 117 Avenue of The Americas
  29. 32
    Burger Joint 118 W 57th St.
  30. 33
    Lucky's Famous Burgers 79 Hudson St.
  31. 34
    Shake Shack 11 Madison Ave.
62 comments
30
1
Danny Meyer knows his stuff.
17
1
freshly made burger, awesome staff
1
get one w/ blue cheese
1
Burger Joint is da bomb.
1
Always a treat
3
1
Get a burger with their curly fries
Seasoned curly fries, I hope.
28
1
Best burgers in Williamsburg! I always get the dumont burger with gruyere cheese and caramelized onions and onion rings on the side. Rich, filling and delicious! There is a small seating area with dim lighting and a communal dining table. Trendy atmosphere. Cocktails too.
24
1
Went there just the other day! My best friend assured me it was worth the wait. After more than an hour of waiting and after tasting their infamous Bronte burger, I would wait as long as need be to get my hands on another one of those. Bonus: the staff was very friendly and accommodating as well.
27
1
The measuring stick for all burgers. Roquefort fan or not, this is a MUST-TRY for any burger aficionado. The meat is so rich and juicy, but complimented perfectly by a generous layering of such a sharp cheese. *** Bono and The Edge sat at the table next to me.
1
best burger ever. period.
3
2
Organic, unusual and fun
26
1
I've a heart and passion for great burgers, which are far too often associated with being fast food. The Mercer Burger is a real gem. For 15$, the burger features pepperjack cheese, avocado, crunchy red onions, russian dressing, and french fries. That's nice.
7
1
High quality meat, great cooking method, fantastic burger
25
1
There's just nothing like it. Except for, well, In n Out..... (california pride!)
25
1
goodburger - I can't believe it either, but this place has great burgers and sides
1
Shake Shack without question.
25
1
Another vote for Shake Shack!
22
1
Frites 'n' Meats. It may be a food truck, but don't let it fool you. The best burger I have ever eaten came from these guys.
23
1
Stand4
12
1
Minetta Tavern rocks it, on Minetta Lane of course
1
Shake Shack - The Shroom Burger is amazing! Get there at an off time to avoid long lines.
28
1
mcdonalds and burger king and wendys
2
@BurgerJoint
1
14
1
Jackson Hole or Smith & Wollensky - Washington D.C. (Pinchy's tip: get to Wollensky Grill through the side entrance)
1
1
Shake Shack is the best!
1
Black Iron Burger is obviously the best. Burgerweekly.com even gushed over it.
13
1
Shake Shack for the down and dirty goodness (get the Shack Stack!) I also like @Bare Burger for their organic and wide variety of meats (Ostrich burger anyone?)
1
28
1
Love DuMont Burger ! Plus some seriously tasty mac and cheese.
1
BLT Corporate Office is by far the best burger I have had in the city. They are always cooked perfect and always juicy not to mention they have alcoholic milkshakes how could you go wrong!
1
5 Napkin Burger - I was very hesitant to go here since it's a chain restaurant and a touristy one at that. It's right in my neighborhood in Hells Kitchen and I finally decided to try it out one day. The Classic is mouth watering. Cooked to perfection the meat is juicy and savory and filled with flavor. The classic comes with a rosemary aioli, gyuere cheese and carmalized onions, you definitely can't go wrong.
You can't beat it ........and those crispy onions! It gets very crowded, though; so make a reservation; this is not just a "burger joint" but is always filled with theater goers from out of town!
1
Shake Shack. Every burger I have had since then has been a let down. From the flakey bun, to the perfectly blended milk shake, that place is as close to perfection as a burger joint can get.
1
I'm a veggie but I do love me a delicious veggie burger. In Manhattan, Shake Shack for sure. In Brooklyn, Mother's on Graham Ave is the best.